America’s Test Kitchen Pizza Peel

America’s test kitchen pizza peel. The greatest pizza peel is the one that makes preparing and eating your favorite meal easier.

Consider being able to slide a cheesy, doughy slice of goodness right off its flatbread onto an oven rack for good, bubbling results without even dirtying another utensil.

What about those who don’t have access to metal or wooden cutting boards (though we suggest investing in both). While you may be paranoid about this, it’s nothing to be concerned about.

Today, there are also polystyrene ones available for purchase; they’re just waiting by their side until they’re needed most during meal preparation sessions.

Here we listed the top 6 products of kitchen pizza peel.

6 America’s Test Kitchen Pizza Peel

1. New Star Foodservice 50295 Restaurant-Grade

america's test kitchen pizza peel

The New Star Foodservice 50295 16″ x 14″ Wood Pizza Peel is made of solid, durable basswood with a smooth, uniform texture that reduces cracking and the production of seeping oils.

A tapered half-inch blade on this wood pizza peel enables you to easily slide underneath and remove pizza from a distance.

This product differs from all other conventional pinewood pizza peels on the market due to its consistent even texture.

The blade is extremely flimsy, and it can be easily bent. The handle has a protective covering that must be removed with a peel, which takes several minutes because you don’t want to remove it all in one go as you use the peel.

Overall, this isn’t a fantastic item, but for those who don’t mind these flaws, it’s worth considering. Even texture prevents peels from producing sebum, which can end up in your food.

The blade is 13.5″ long and 9″ wide, and it’s 1/2″ thick and comprised of solid basswood with a smooth, uniform texture that prevents cracking.

The handle has a protective covering that must be removed with a peel, which takes several minutes since you don’t want to remove it all at once while using it.

2. Chef Pomodoro Aluminum Metal Pizza Peel

chef pomodoro aluminum

This is the finest pizza peel available. It was created particularly for home chefs, artisan bakers, and pizza makers.

This commercial-grade aluminum is manufactured from high-quality aluminum for durability and withstanding high temperatures.

The Chef Goods Pomodoro Aluminum Metal Pizza Peel with Foldable Wood Handle is made of anodized aluminum and features a foldable wooden handle that can be used to remove the pizza from a gas or wood-fired oven.

For storage, the paddle’s 11-inch foldable wooden handle may be placed over a broiler. The paddle is 14 inches long and 12-1/2 inches broad, with one side slightly raised to allow cheese and toppings to easily slide onto your pizza as it cooks.

This heavy-duty paddle is constructed of commercial-grade aluminum that won’t rust or corrode with time.

Its unusual form has smooth edges, so you don’t get ingredients caught as you load your favorite meals on top of your delicious handmade dough.

This chef’s selection has four rubber feet on the wooden handle and a contoured edge that guides the pizza without deforming its form or disturbing the toppings.

3. “American Metalcraft 2512 26”

american metalcraft 2512

The American Metalcraft 12″ x 14″ Aluminum Pizza Peel with a 10″ Wood Handle is a must-have for any baker.

It’s made of sturdy aluminum and triple-riveted ferrules, making it ideal for making medium-sized pizzas.

The 10″ wooden handle keeps your hands away from the heat while providing a smooth, comfortable grip.

Your pizza will slide right off this pizza peel with just a dusting of flour or cornmeal. To create a more rustic and genuine appearance, bring it to the table for serving.

Aside from its apparent practical applications, there are a few things you might not be aware of regarding this useful kitchen tool.

If you thought that peeling potatoes would make good use of the handle, think again. This pizza peel should never be used as a salad spinner or a hot pad, despite how handy it is in the kitchen.

If you’re thinking of using your peel to keep insects away from your picnic table, think again.

You won’t want to use your pizza peel as an ice cream scoop or an egg slicer unless you don’t mind tasting aluminum with every bite. There are other options try the Norpro Handled Ice Cream Scoop instead.

4. Epicurean Pizza Peel, 21-Inch by 14-Inch

epicurean pizza peel, 21 inch by 14 inch, natural

The Epicurean Pizza Peel is a must-have for moving pizza from your oven to the table.

This peel is both environmentally friendly and long-lasting thanks to its 100 percent recycled construction.

The side with the smooth surface may be used to slide your pizza onto the stone or griddle, while the rough side can be used for a more secure hold on a sticky dough by flipping it over.

Each Pizza Peel is created by hand by expert American artisans who take pleasure in their work and dedication to quality. As a result, you get an elegant as well as a practical tool that you will enjoy using for years.

We want to assist our clients in creating special memories around the pleasures of preparing and eating food.

We’re here to spread the epicurean lifestyle, which is about appreciating fine cuisine with family and friends, spending time in nature, and doing what we love most.

Tell us how we may help you create more memorable moments in your kitchen. For years, I’ve been making my pizzas in my cast iron skillet.

5. Premium Aluminum Pizza Peel

premium aluminum pizza peel

The aluminum pizza peel is of excellent quality. The handle is made of all-natural oak wood with a leather rope. It’s durable and high-quality.

TDHDIKE Aluminum Pizza Peel for transferring pizzas, bread, and other baked items to and from the oven, BBQ, and any other oven or Plate.

Compatible with U3, most commercial pizza ovens, and accessories, Pizzeria Pronto, Green Egg, Mastercraft Folding design for easy storage; fits in any corner of any kitchen.

which makes them resemble a shovel with a long handle that is positioned horizontally instead of vertically.

They also have an interesting look, which may appeal to consumers who enjoy the more unique designs.

Because they can be leaned up against a rack or other cooking utensils when going through a tiny kitchen pass-through window but have no use outside of any professional kitchen setting unless.

6. SPLENDR Aluminum Metal Pizza Peel

splendr aluminum metal

This is a pizza peel with a rectangular shape that measures 12″ x 14″. It’s constructed of sturdy aluminum metal for long-lasting use.

A foldable wood handle makes it easy to store in your kitchen cabinet or pantry, and the handle has an ergonomic shape making transporting pizzas easier, even if you have arthritis or other mobility problems.

The Steel Cut Pizzeria’s pizza peel is constructed of heavy-duty aluminum that keeps it from skidding about on the table as you work with it.

Because it assists you in preparing your dough, removing it from the oven, and cutting your pizza successfully, this device may be used by both experienced and inexperienced chefs.

The Good It fits virtually anywhere without taking up too much shelf or counter space. The Bad Its ergonomic design makes it comfy to use, but it makes it difficult for people with smaller hands to grasp.

The Bottom Line This peel is designed for general usage and is perfect for beginners due to its size and simplicity of use.

If you want a larger wooden handle, this may not be the ideal option for you, but it does include rubber feet to prevent slipping when in use.


1. Do you cook pizza on a peel?

The tiny, circular peel is a must-have for rotating and transferring pizzas in your oven. It’s smaller than many of the other choices on the market, making it simple to handle while also allowing you to remove cooked pizzas without them sagging over after eating.

2. What to do if pizza sticks to peel?

The simplest way to remove a pizza from the peel is with a quick back-and-forth stroke. Thrust your peel in front of you, aiming for that ideal middle region where it rebounds like an accordion; then jerk away smoothly.


America’s test kitchen pizza peel. The pizza peel is one of the oldest cooking utensils in existence, and it has evolved to become a key element in an efficient kitchen.  Well, that depends on your needs.

Today’s offerings give us all sorts of options when shopping around. Let America’s Test Kitchen be your guide as we explore which type of pizza tool will work best based on how often you cook at home and what types of foods you usually make.

Related Guides

Leave a Comment